Tails of Truth: The Truth about Veterinary Medicine

Positive Dog Training with Brooke Fagel: No Pain to Train

• Dr. Angie Krause, DVM CVA CCRT • Episode 82

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 36:49

Tell Us What You Think

Positive dog training, e-collars, reactive dogs, and the truth about alpha training. Dr. Angie and JoJo talk with dog trainer Brooke Fagel of Majestic Dog Training about why you never have to hurt a dog to train one.

Brooke explains why punishment can look like it works while burying a dog’s warning signs, and why positive training is about far more than treats. JoJo opens up about the shame of living with a dog who’s afraid of people. Dr. Angie shares the day a golden retriever growled at her for the first time in 20 years of practice.

They also cover doodles and breeding for temperament, when it’s okay not to rescue, little dog syndrome, dogs fighting in the same home, rehoming, and how to find a positive trainer.

Find Brooke at majesticdogtraining.com and @majesticdogtraining

Book a consultation with Dr. Angie at boulderholisticvet.com

Key Takeaways

  • Positive training uses food as a starting tool, not a permanent crutch. The goal is to build on it skill by skill.
  • Dogs aren’t trying to dominate their people. Letting your dog sleep in your bed doesn’t make them think they’re in charge.
  • Punishment can produce obedience on the surface while damaging the relationship and creating fear underneath.
  • E-collars can suppress a dog’s early warning signals, like soft eyes or a head tilt. When those dogs finally react, the reaction can be more intense. Brooke is seeing more and more dogs come to her after e-collar training.
  • Many reactive dogs can improve a great deal. Some become lifelong management cases, and accepting a dog’s limits is part of setting them up for success.
  • Brooke is seeing more behavior issues in doodles, which she connects to breeding for low shedding rather than temperament.
  • Choosing a breed that fits your lifestyle is a responsible choice. A poor rescue match can lead to dogs and people getting hurt.
  • Small dogs need training too. Their bite histories often go unaddressed because the behavior gets laughed off.
  • Fearful dogs often learn faster in a neutral, new environment before practicing skills at home.
  • When dogs in the same home are fighting and living separated, a lot of stress has already built up. Rehoming can be the kind choice, and planning introductions ahead of time can prevent the problem.
  • A spray bottle usually teaches a dog to fear the bottle rather than changing the behavior.
  • A few skills taught really well, like settle, touch, or watch me, can help a dog stay calm at the vet.
  • Several European countries have banned or restricted e-collar use.

Soundbites 

“I could never fathom harming my dog to train my dog.” — Brooke Fagel

“But sometimes they’re actually not ready for what they’re rescuing.”  — Dr. Angie

“You get maybe the same end result like the dog obeys, if you will... but the relationship is not good.” — JoJo  

“I really, passionately want people to know that there’s help with training a dog and you don’t have to harm them ever.” — Brooke Fagel

“Last week I had a golden retriever growl at me for the first time in my career.”      — Dr. Angie

“Sometimes I think there’s such a desperation to put the dog in a home, but not necessarily the well matched home.” — JoJo 

“I don’t need to get bit to see that your dog bites. I got it.” — Brooke Fagel

“I know your dog doesn’t want to kill me, but they also just don’t want me to like get their blood or vaccinate them.” — Dr. Angie 

“I’m gonna say it out loud because I feel shame around it.” — JoJo

“But there’s no shame at all. It’s all fixable and it is daunting ’cause not having a perfect dog is difficult.” — Brooke Fagel

Please subscribe and review! xoxo Dr. Angie & JoJo